Although I have a great deal to say in praise of Andy Ngo's book, I do not have praise only: he really relegated veganism to a minor, descriptive element of the Zizian movement/cult. It isn't. Veganism is crucial to understanding the history of the Zizians and the Zizians are crucial to understanding the future of veganism —as I have warned so many times, this is a contest for no ordinary prize, but whether we are to be sane or insane.
There is a significant difference in emphasis found in this relatively boring (or, at least, "unadorned") news article by Anna Bauman: "Berkeley man, missing for two years, ‘left everything behind’ to join Zizians." LINK: https://openvallejo.org/2025/02/17/berkeley-man-missing-for-two-years-left-everything-behind-to-join-zizians/
In Bauman's article, this is "a cult-like group of vegan anarchists" —they are primarily vegan and only secondarily transgender.
One flaw this article has in common with Andy Ngo's book is readily referring to these people as extremely intelligent or even suggesting the possibility that they could be geniuses: on the contrary, without exception, we are talking about horrifyingly stupid people —with or without their individual diagnoses for mental disabilities being included in the calculation.
On some level, be it shallow or profound, neither Ngo nor Bauman want to accept that any idiot can get a university degree in computer science and remain an idiot thereafter. Yes, some of these people had impressive-sounding credentials: there was nothing intellectually impressive about them, as people.
I made many, many videos explaining (at a slow pace, for a stupid audience) that the problem with the vegan movement as it then existed was not that it was misperceived (by meat eaters) as insane but that it genuinely was insane: it required vegans to believe impossible things, and rewarded them for preaching these impossibilities with religious conviction, driving its most devoted adherents insane if they weren't insane to begin with. By the time I wrote my book, Veganism: Future of an Illusion, this was no longer my primary concern or focus, having already "talked it to death" on the youtube channel over so many years. The book does not summarize previous discussions on the channel: it is an original "step forward" from what had already been explained on the channel, and does not repeat earlier material. I remember one fan saying that he was looking forward to the book dealing with (e.g.) the wildlife management hypothesis, but in those pages you will find nothing of the kind. Broadly speaking, over the last decade, vegans have been concerned too much with optics and too little with the reality of things themselves —including the reality of the insanity of veganism and vegans.
I say again —and only for the second time— that without surrealists there would be no surrealism. Veganism, likewise, must be understood as a kind of creative co-operation betwixt and between some small number of vegans: it is not now and never was "a mass movement" akin to mobs of starving peasants demanding bread. Caring about the future of surrealism entails a kind of care for particular intellectuals who "are" surrealists, really meaning that they could be surrealists, but could also take on some other kind of project (working in some other genre with the same set of skills) instead; so too, caring about the future of veganism entails that we care about individual vegans. Talent is scarce, and talented people always have something better to do.